Sesnan questions Tower Hamlet insourcing decision – says it will increase costs by £2.1m a year
– Mark Sesnan, CEO GLL
Mark Sesnan, CEO of GLL, has pushed back on Tower Hamlet Council’s decision to take the operation of its leisure services back in-house when GLL’s contract ends in April 2024, saying it will increase costs.
Sesnan told HCM “We’re obviously extremely disappointed with the decision to change delivery arrangements, particularly given the clear recommendations of an independent Leisure Recommissioning Report, which advised that the current delivery model offers the best value-for-money.“
He said “We’ve always maintained excellent working relationships with Tower Hamlet Council and will continue to work closely with them as we approach 2024, however, it’s hard to understand why some councils have decided that insourcing their leisure centres is in the interests of customers, the staff or the wider community; particularly as – in the case of Tower Hamlets, it has been calculated by the independent review that it will cost local ratepayers an additional £2.1m every year.
“Insourcing will also stifle staff career opportunities and restrict customer choice, as their access to leisure services will be limited to ‘home borough facilities only’ – but it is of course the council’s right to so choose,” he said.
Tower Hamlets Council is the latest London authority to take direct control of its leisure services, following Southwark and Lambeth Councils.
Tower Hamlets currently owns seven leisure centres, which have been managed by GLL for the past 18 years.
To accompany the announcement, the council pledged to invest £35m in leisure, as part of a renewed focus on providing a service that "benefits hard-to-reach communities", such as BAME women and children with special educational needs.
The £35m investment in services revealed by the council includes the building of a new leisure centre in Shadwell.
According to Lutfur Rahman, mayor of Tower Hamlets, the decision to insource services aligns with the council’s leisure strategy, to "enable and support local people to live healthier and physically active lives".
“It is important for local people to have access to high-quality facilities to play sport, stay healthy and come together as a community," Rahman said.
"The decision to bring leisure services in-house is as much about public health as it is about managing our services on behalf of residents.
"The new leisure centre at St George’s (in Shadwell) will be a great asset for local people and demonstrates our commitment to providing affordable and accessible facilities and housing for residents,” he said.
However, Sesnan said GLL has already been offering strong support for community access and inclusion, commenting: “As a staff-owned charitable social enterprise, we're proud of the progress we’ve made providing leisure services to the local Tower Hamlets community over the past 18 years. During that time we’ve consistently invested in the local area and worked with all ages, fitness levels, ethnicities and cultures to promote the benefits of exercise to residents’ physical health and mental wellbeing.
“Initiatives we’ve delivered in Tower Hamlets include highly successful targeted women-only swimming, gym and activity sessions, intensive learn to swim classes for children from deprived backgrounds and a Young at Heart activity programme for older people. We also provide financial and practical support to talented young athletes from Tower Hamlets through our GLL Sport Foundation.”
The council's decision has sparked discussion among industry thought leaders – including on the LinkedIn open forum, where one commentator expressed the opinion that insourcing – particularly through a pure in-house model – will almost always result in higher costs compared to procuring a leisure contract through a multi-site operator.
However, it was acknowledged that some councils are looking to take more control of their services and for them to work as part of a wider health and wellbeing system and that they're prepared to pay to fund this.
It was ultimately deemed unlikely that we'll see a major shift back to insourcing, as many councils don't have the capacity or desire to run services themselves.
Neil Hutchinson, MD of Bolton Middlebrook Leisure Trust – and former head of group operations at Burnley Leisure Trust – said: “It feels as though the industry is going full circle.
"I started my career with the council in-house before moving to a trust – and now I see many going back to in-house or using LATCos.
"We need to get consistency across the country so users have the same opportunities and variety of services and facilities everywhere. Another exciting time to be in the industry,” he said.
Dan Flahive, centre manager at Circadian Trust, said: "Interesting to see this and if more councils follow suit.
"Councils taking on leisure facilities need to maintain high standards in operation, as this is where they've fallen down in the past. Interesting times."
Some in the industry see the decision as a, trend with an increasing number of councils opting to bring services in-house or to adopt a LATCo model, as a way to manage costs, generate revenue and deliver positive outcomes.
GLL Tower Hamlets leisure services Mark Sesnan Lutfur RahmanLGA and ukactive call for fundamental reform of UK public leisure services
FEATURE: News report – Tackling inequality
FEATURE: Everyone’s talking about – Insourcing
UAE’s first Dior Spa debuts in Dubai at Dorchester Collection’s newest hotel, The Lana
Europe's premier Evian Spa unveiled at Hôtel Royal in France
Clinique La Prairie unveils health resort in China after two-year project
GoCo Health Innovation City in Sweden plans to lead the world in delivering wellness and new science
Four Seasons announces luxury wellness resort and residences at Amaala
Aman sister brand Janu debuts in Tokyo with four-floor urban wellness retreat
€38m geothermal spa and leisure centre to revitalise Croatian city of Bjelovar
Two Santani eco-friendly wellness resorts coming to Oman, partnered with Omran Group
Kerzner shows confidence in its Siro wellness hotel concept, revealing plans to open 100
Ritz-Carlton, Portland unveils skyline spa inspired by unfolding petals of a rose
Rogers Stirk Harbour & Partners are just one of the names behind The Emory hotel London and Surrenne private members club
Peninsula Hot Springs unveils AUS$11.7m sister site in Australian outback
IWBI creates WELL for residential programme to inspire healthy living environments
Conrad Orlando unveils water-inspired spa oasis amid billion-dollar Evermore Resort complex
Studio A+ realises striking urban hot springs retreat in China's Shanxi Province
Populous reveals plans for major e-sports arena in Saudi Arabia
Wake The Tiger launches new 1,000sq m expansion
Othership CEO envisions its urban bathhouses in every city in North America
Merlin teams up with Hasbro and Lego to create Peppa Pig experiences
SHA Wellness unveils highly-anticipated Mexico outpost
One&Only One Za’abeel opens in Dubai featuring striking design by Nikken Sekkei
Luxury spa hotel, Calcot Manor, creates new Grain Store health club
'World's largest' indoor ski centre by 10 Design slated to open in 2025
Murrayshall Country Estate awarded planning permission for multi-million-pound spa and leisure centre
Aman's Janu hotel by Pelli Clarke & Partners will have 4,000sq m of wellness space
Therme Group confirms Incheon Golden Harbor location for South Korean wellbeing resort
Universal Studios eyes the UK for first European resort
King of Bhutan unveils masterplan for Mindfulness City, designed by BIG, Arup and Cistri
Rural locations are the next frontier for expansion for the health club sector
Tonik Associates designs new suburban model for high-end Third Space health and wellness club
Ben Channon has written Happy by Design, a new book about how architecture affects our mental health. He explains how we can all be happier at home
BrunelloCucinelli has madehisfortune from cashmere and has used hiswealthto restoreandrevive theItalian hamlet he callshome. Wefindout more