Niall McLaughlin: Design competitions and awards put 'extraordinary pressure' on architects
– Niall McLaughlin
Acclaimed Irish architect Niall McLaughlin has claimed that award wins and nominations can be a poisoned chalice, as practices become pigeonholed as designers of a certain type of building.
Speaking at the 2017 Ecobuild conference in London, McLaughlin said the influence of award shortlists and the “conservative stance in architectural procurement” means that “everybody wants something like you’ve done before.”
The practice he leads, Niall McLaughlin Architects, have twice been nominated for the UK’s most prestigious architecture award, the Stirling Prize.
“For the three years after we were first shortlisted for the first time [for Oxford’s Bishop Edward King Chapel in 2013] we were approached constantly by cultural institutions and Oxford and Cambridge colleges wanting music performance spaces, museum spaces and cultural spaces,” he said.
“After a couple of years the echo started to die away and the approaches become less frequent. But then we were shortlisted again, in 2015, for a piece of low cost housing in London and suddenly we were being approached by lots of developers wanting low-cost housing.
“So I’m interested, for architects, in the way in which the system of awards and competitions is a generator of the kind of work you do.”
He said this cycle creates “a danger that your work gets cornered in one area and that you end up doing too much of the same thing, which goes against the idea of innovation and of being given new new problems to solve.”
Speaking more broadly about the impact of being shortlisted for awards, McLaughlin revealed that “85 per cent of all the work we do comes from design competitions, and we get shortlisted for those competitions by winning awards.”
“We produce work that gets consumed through the awards system and approved of, and that approval gets converted into approaches for more work, closing the loop,” he added.
Despite the benefits of this cycle, he said “the idea that buildings are always being offered up in a competitive system is something I find, to put it bluntly, very tiring,” adding that “it “puts an extraordinary pressure on architectural practices”.
Explaining how he has ensured he has a diverse portfolio of work, McLaughlin said: “You need to find ways of reviving your own practice by pushing yourself out into areas that are different from what you have been doing before.”
The architect was speaking as part of a Q&A session hosted by BBC Arts editor Will Gompertz, in which he also discussed his views on modernism, materials and metropolitan planning.
Last year he was awarded the annual RIBA Charles Jencks Award, which celebrates individuals who have made a major contribution internationally to the theory and practice of architecture. His studio's next high-profile project is an extension to London's National History Museum.
Ecobuild is one of the world’s biggest trade events for sustainable design, construction and the built environment.
This is not the first time in recent months that design competitions have come in for criticism. Wolf Prix, the design principal of Austrian architecture studio Coop Himmelb(l)au, argued last year that they “diminish the value of our thinking”.
Niall McLaughlin architecture design Ecobuild Stirling PrizeNiall McLaughlin Architects and Purcell win Auckland Castle Museum contract
Niall McLaughlin Architects wins Natural History Museum redevelopment contest
Aman sister brand Janu debuts in Tokyo with four-floor urban wellness retreat
€38m geothermal spa and leisure centre to revitalise Croatian city of Bjelovar
Two Santani eco-friendly wellness resorts coming to Oman, partnered with Omran Group
Kerzner shows confidence in its Siro wellness hotel concept, revealing plans to open 100
Ritz-Carlton, Portland unveils skyline spa inspired by unfolding petals of a rose
Rogers Stirk Harbour & Partners are just one of the names behind The Emory hotel London and Surrenne private members club
Peninsula Hot Springs unveils AUS$11.7m sister site in Australian outback
IWBI creates WELL for residential programme to inspire healthy living environments
Conrad Orlando unveils water-inspired spa oasis amid billion-dollar Evermore Resort complex
Studio A+ realises striking urban hot springs retreat in China's Shanxi Province
Populous reveals plans for major e-sports arena in Saudi Arabia
Wake The Tiger launches new 1,000sq m expansion
Othership CEO envisions its urban bathhouses in every city in North America
Merlin teams up with Hasbro and Lego to create Peppa Pig experiences
SHA Wellness unveils highly-anticipated Mexico outpost
One&Only One Za’abeel opens in Dubai featuring striking design by Nikken Sekkei
Luxury spa hotel, Calcot Manor, creates new Grain Store health club
'World's largest' indoor ski centre by 10 Design slated to open in 2025
Murrayshall Country Estate awarded planning permission for multi-million-pound spa and leisure centre
Aman's Janu hotel by Pelli Clarke & Partners will have 4,000sq m of wellness space
Therme Group confirms Incheon Golden Harbor location for South Korean wellbeing resort
Universal Studios eyes the UK for first European resort
King of Bhutan unveils masterplan for Mindfulness City, designed by BIG, Arup and Cistri
Rural locations are the next frontier for expansion for the health club sector
Tonik Associates designs new suburban model for high-end Third Space health and wellness club
Aman sister brand Janu launching in Tokyo in 2024 with design by Denniston's Jean-Michel Gathy
The Peninsula London unveils Peter Marino-designed spa inspired by London’s famous parks
First glimpses revealed of Mandarin Oriental, Mayfair's subterranean spa retreat
"Architecture is alive" says Ma Yansong, as Shenzhen art museum opens exhibition showcasing work of MAD Architects
SHA Mexico to debut in January 2024 with genome-inspired design by Sordo Madaleno
Why shouldn’t sports facilities be beautiful? Across Asia, architects are creating landmark buildings for the public, discovers Christopher de Wolf
How Portugal’s biggest brewer enlisted the help of one of the country’s best known architects to turn two historic nature parks into thermal spa and nature destinations
Designing an eco hotel for the Galapagos Islands that allowed the stunning natural surroundings to take centre stage while minimising its impact on the land presented its own unique set of challenges, Ecuadorian architect Humberto Plaza tells Kathryn Hudson