Urban Planning

Planning for health

At Space Syntax, research and analysis are helping define how urban professionals have a role to play in achieving healthy outcomes for all. Eime Tobari and Eleri Jones discuss some of the findings


Read on turning pages | Download PDF | sign up to CLAD

Until recently, the relevance of health to the realm of urban planning and design was not widely accepted or acknowledged. Now, however, there is a common understanding globally that health is a complex issue that relates to all aspects of our everyday lives and is influenced by the built environment, as well as by sociocultural and economic factors.

In our increasingly complex and interrelated urban environments, this means that positive health outcomes must be considered holistically and cannot be focused on particular segments of the population. This statement was recognised by the 9th Global Conference on Health Promotion, which was held in Shanghai, China, in the November of 2016, when the goal of “health for all, all for health” was agreed upon and was furthermore referenced by Chinese president Xi Jinping in his opening speech at the event.

Politicians, at both the city and national levels, will play a critical role in ensuring that positive health outcomes for all are prioritised. However, professionals in urban planning and design around the world are well positioned to take a lead role on this agenda by creating places that support better health outcomes and the wellbeing of citizens in urban areas, many of which are growing at a rapid pace.

Design options and health outcomes
A number of guidelines and tools have been developed by multilaterals, governmental and voluntary sector organisations to ensure that positive health outcomes are included in decision-making processes at every governance level. At the international level, the World Health Organisation (WHO) published a Health Economic Assessment Tool (HEAT) that estimates the economic impact of walking and cycling. They also promote the Health Impact Assessment (HIA), which is a framework to assess the health impact of policies, urban planning and development projects. Sustrans, in partnership with TAS Partnership and Living Streets, developed an Active Travel Toolbox, which links health outcomes with investment, housing growth and air quality. Transport for London published Healthy Streets for London, which includes guidelines in promoting active travel (walking, cycling and public transport).

While all of these toolkits and guidelines are very helpful in terms of highlighting the importance of good health outcomes, in practice, the principles which underpin these guidelines are often not applied to urban planning and design decisions. This is in part because there is a lack of quantifiable measures which urban professionals can use to objectively test the impact that design options might have on health outcomes.

Using urban layouts
Space Syntax is an approach to understanding how the spatial structure of places impacts movement and behaviour. Recent advances in our analytical capability have enabled us to start to investigate how health outcomes are impacted by the spatial structure of urban areas. This research has led us to develop tools which allow for a quantitative assessment of different policy interventions, such as increasing public transport provision in underserved areas.

It is generally accepted that increased public transport provision improves access to services and employment. This in turn can have a positive impact on health, both physical and mental, as it reduces social isolation and encourages people to undertake active travel. While these associations are well known, it is not easy to identify where exactly the improved public transportation should be routed to ensure it improves the lives of the people that need it the most.

Street network analysis
Through Space Syntax analysis, we can provide insights with this level of granularity, enabling evidence-based decisions on a range of possible policy interventions. For example, analysis of the maps on the opposite page can demonstrate why there is a high level of car dependency in Milton Keynes: the street network, when combined with public transport availability and where jobs are located, means that private vehicles become a natural choice for a large portion of the population. The maps can also then show policymakers precisely which parts of the city would benefit most from greater public transport availability.

On the other hand, the London Borough of Greenwich, shown in the image on the right, has a spatial structure which is far more ‘compact’. Our analysis of the street network in the image below shows how many different land uses are available within a five-minute walking distance from many residential buildings. The warmer the colour is, the more types of land uses residents can reach within five minutes, on foot.

What this analysis means in practice is that policy makers can see that many residents in this area are able to access effective town, local and neighbourhood centres. This means cars are less likely to be a necessity for day-to-day activities (apart from perhaps a commute to work, which is not included in this analysis) and therefore air pollution is likely to be lower. Residents are also likely to be getting regular exercise as they go about their daily lives. However, even in this compact urban layout, there are still areas that are relatively segregated. Using this tool, planners can see precisely where these areas are and what additional public transport would be most effective to improve access to local services for people living there.

Creating healthier places
The outputs of these tools, and the conclusions derived from them, may appear to be a statement of the obvious, which are underpinned by relatively simple analyses. However, two overarching lessons for those involved in planning and designing cities can be drawn from them. Firstly, our analysis demonstrates how significant a factor spatial structure is in encouraging active travel. Streets form the foundation of our urban fabric and are not as easy to change as public realm or individual buildings. It is therefore crucial that this foundation is designed to encourage behaviours that contribute to better health and supports creation of healthier places.

By this, we mean a built environment that supports and promotes the physical and mental health of the people who use it. This requires the right balance of interconnectedness, movement, awareness, encounter and exchange at every scale. It means the delivery of places in which different kinds of human activity can thrive - as demonstrated in the case study on the opposite page, which is a proposal for improving the layout of Union Square in Washington, DC. Space Syntax proposed improving exiting routes and crossing points, which increased walkability around the square as well as creating resting spots to watch other people from – one of the main activities in public places.

Secondly, while the links between urban form and health outcomes are accepted and well known, the application of systematic, quantitatively driven analysis to inform specific planning decisions is not commonplace. Instead, generalised principles are applied in a broad-brush manner to all urban environments, without considering the unique spatial characteristics that impact how they function and how they influence behaviours.

A targeted application of the very sound principles set out in documents such as the HIA is required to deliver the known health benefits of, for example, active travel. This requires complex models that combine a range of datasets spatially, such as the ones shown above. At Space Syntax, these models are called Integrated Urban Models and they link urban planning and design parameters, such as street layout, land use, plot sizes and development quantum, with health-related outcomes such as walkability and car dependency – and allow us to see interactions between them. An example of this can be seen on the following page, which shows the proposed master plan of Darwin city centre in Australia and the creation of a new, local, walkable centre in an Extension Area.

A data-driven and spatial approach
Health is important to all of us and, of course, to our future generations. So why has the topic not been a top priority in urban planning and design discussions? It is not necessarily because urban planners or designers do not recognise its importance – it is because integrating health outcomes into the decision-making process is very challenging.

We have seen how using data and sophisticated modelling techniques, such as those detailed above, can help to make this task easier. However, this cannot be undertaken by planners alone. There is still a need for open, collaborative discussion across professions, disciplines and sectors, underpinned by robust evidence and principles, if design is to realise positive health outcomes for all citizens. Health should be a central topic throughout the process of planning and design from strategic spatial strategy, transport strategy and land use allocations through to public realm and building design.

For this process to be efficient and effective, a collaboration between planning, transport and public health teams in particular is essential. There are already some exciting, formalised collaborations in existence. For example, Transport for London has a public health expert who is pushing a healthy places agenda. In the UK, the Local Government and Public Involvement in Health Act 2007 requires Primary Care Trusts to work with Local Authorities to develop a Joint Strategic Needs Assessment (JSNA), which links various functions of Local Authorities with health issues and promotes collaborations between a range of departments.

Time to act
Such collaborations can also be supported and facilitated by sharing datasets and models. This can help align work in different teams by creating a common ground, which also makes cross-team communications easier. In this way, data and modelling can provide a common language between various experts and facilitate collaborations between them.

But we also need to go beyond talking and start acting if we are to avoid the very real challenges that poor health-related outcomes pose for the future generations who inhabit our cities. We know, through careful analysis of evidence and case studies, that positive health outcomes can be delivered through a variety of design decisions that typically require insights and inputs from many different disciplines and professions.

We now need to apply focused, localised data analytics to identify exactly where that expertise and insight can be applied to best effect, creating a planning and design process which can respond to the specific needs of the people that live in our cities.

Urban planning

Milton Keynes

The images show the number of job opportunities (commercial uses) in Milton Keynes reachable in 15-minute journeys in each transport mode. The darker it is, more job opportunities available within 15-minute journeys. Car dependency was calculated as a ratio between the number of job opportunities available within the same journey time between public transport and private vehicles. The darker is it, the greater the advantage of private vehicles is. The closer to pale grey, the closer the advantage of both transport modes are. However, in this case, the public transport option does not outweigh private vehicles.

Private car
Private car
Private car vs Public Transport
Private car vs Public Transport
Public Transport
Public Transport
Walking
Walking

London Borough of Greenwich

Different land use types within a five-minute walk

Union Square, Washington, DC

Union Square is located at the eastern end of the National Mall and in front of the State Capitol Building. The design proposal extends the exiting east-west routes of the National Mall straight into the heart of the space. Combined with improved crossing points, this will enhance the connection between the National Mall and the space.

In Union Square, a series of convenient diagonal routes connect visitors with strategic points in the pedestrian movement network, such as the roundabouts at the ends of Pennsylvania, Maryland and Louisiana Avenues.

A new north-south link is introduced along the alignment of Second Street connecting the site better locally and with the US Botanical Gardens. Within this network, new spaces to rest and enjoy the Square and its significant views are created around the basins and at the basin of the Grant Memorial. These locations will be excellent spots for watching people, a main activity in public space. Such stationary activity will contribute to the attraction of this space, which will increase significantly as a result of the redesign. The combined impact of the proposed spatial interventions would have a significant impact on pedestrian activity potentials within the space as well as on the eastern part of the National Mall.

Darwin, Australia

In 2012, the City of Darwin secured a grant from the Commonwealth Government of Australia to produce a master plan for the city centre of Darwin. The purpose of this plan is to provide a road map for development of the city for the next 20 years. To accommodate growth, the city centre needs to be extended and reinforced. Space Syntax was asked to join a design team led by Design Urban. Our role was to provide comprehensive urban analysis and strategic design input to support the creation of the master plan. A key aim of the project was to facilitate private sector investment and population growth through the production of high quality public realm.

Space Syntax’s work has underpinned the creation of the Darwin City Centre Master Plan. Quantified indications of its social and economic impacts have facilitated meaningful discussions between different disciplines, bringing architects, transport engineers, planners and politicians together with a wide stakeholder base.

About the authors

Eime Jones and Eime Tobari
Eime Jones and Eime Tobari

Eleri Jones, associate at Space Syntax, leads the Urban Policy and Foresight team, which supports the strategic development and growth of the company through research and stakeholder engagement activities. Prior to this, Jones led the Foresight Future of Cities project in the UK Government Office for Science and held a variety of posts in the Cabinet Office and DCLG.

Dr Eime Tobari, associate director at Space Syntax, has extensive research experience in architecture and sociology, focusing on the relationship between space and its behavioural, social and economic outcomes. She has been involved with projects ranging from the internal layout of buildings to city-wide masterplanning. Tobari has been focusing on promoting a health and wellbeing agenda in urban planning and design.

Gallery
Click on an image to open the image gallery
company profile
Company profile: SPARCSTUDIO
Sparcstudio offers a bespoke and comprehensive design service with real attention to detail. Logical and inspiring space planning forms the bedrock of all Sparcstudio projects.
Try cladmag for free!
Sign up with CLAD to receive our regular ezine, instant news alerts, free digital subscriptions to CLADweek, CLADmag and CLADbook and to request a free sample of the next issue of CLADmag.
sign up
features
MVVA are leading the design of the Ralph C. Wilson Jr Centennial Park
Van Valkenburgh studied landscape architecture and fine arts at Cornell University and the University of Illinois
"Building a park is the ultimate act of democracy"

The US landscape architect on why the Obamas are his kind of clients

CLAD people: Kanye West
West announced the donation to the Roden Crater after a recent visit
"We will all live in Turrell spaces one day"

Musician Kanye West to help fund the still unfinished Roden Crater, designed by American artist James Turrell

Colli is known for her use of colour
Daniela Colli
"The alternation of light and shadow is essential to give dynamism to a space"

Italian architect Daniela Colli tells us how she looked to classical art for inspiration on how to deal with light and shadow in her latest project

Catalogue Gallery
Click on a catalogue to view it online
To advertise in our catalogue gallery: call +44(0)1462 431385
features
The playground at Dokk1 was a seminal project
Ole Barslund Nielsen founded Monstrum in 2003 with Christian Jensen. The two met when working in theatre scenography
"Failing and falling can be a good thing"

How his background in theatre set design inspired Ole Barslund Nielsen to create playgrounds with a difference

Champalimaud designed all of the hotel’s interiors
Bakos joined Champalimaud in December 2012. He previously worked for the Rockwell Group
"Construction is one of the largest generators of landfill waste, so it is important to create spaces that transcend trends"

It’s time for a new approach to sustainability, argues Champalimaud’s managing director

The Newspaper Cafe in Jinhua Architecture Park, China
Born in Kobe, Japan and later growing up in New York, Mori has become a trailblazer for women in architecture around the world
"Every decision you make, you should think seven generations ahead"

From a compressed earth cultural centre in Senegal to the sleek Center for Maine Contemporary Art, Mori’s work shares a clarity of purpose

features
David Polzin is executive director of design at CannonDesign. He studied at Columbia University Graduate School of Architecture
"We were able to create an ‘acoustic shadow’ cutting decibel levels nearly in half"

How to design the perfect community leisure centre 100 13th century pilgrimage The Vietnamese village being created using historic methods

Interview: John Rhodes
John Rhodes
"It’s about the celebration of people coming together. If you can manage that well, a venue can become very special"

HOK has been tasked with designing a truly flexible arena for Valencia. John Rhodes is up for the challenge

The Lyric Theatre Complex is part of Hong Kong’s West Kowloon Cultural District
"I like art that is against the mainstream, slightly off, with a twist"

UNStudio’s co-founder on the unexpected challenges of designing Australia’s tallest skyscraper

featured supplier
Featured Supplier: EXF supports Third Space to create London’s largest functional training space at The Yard
Bespoke fitness manufacturer EXF has extended its relationship with Third Space, by supplying the luxury fitness group with London’s largest functional training rig at its Canary Wharf club.
cladkit product news
Tredje Natur launches Climate Tile to bring green spaces to urban settings
Tredje Natur has installed the pilot system of its Climate Tile system in the Nørrebro area of Copenhagen
Lauren Heath-Jones
Danish company Tredje Natur (Third Nature) has recently installed the pilot system of its innovative street paving system in the ...
Volvo partners with Reef Lab Designs to encourage ocean biodiversity
The tiles are made from marine-grade concrete and recycled plastic fibres
Lauren Heath-Jones
Car manufacturer Volvo has partnered with the Sydney Institute of Marine Science and Reef Design Lab to create an environmentally-friendly ...
John Pawson reimagines oil lantern for Wästberg
The Holocene No. 4 reflects Pawson's pared-back style and neutral palette
Lauren Heath-Jones
Swedish lighting company Wästberg has expanded its Holocene collection, with a new addition, Holocene No. 4, designed by acclaimed architect ...
cladkit product news
Water inspires Zaha Hadid Design x Rosenthal collaboration
The collection consists of three smaller collections: Weave, Strip and Lapp. Weave was inspired by 'the fluid lines of Zaha Hadid's sketching hand'
Lauren Heath-Jones
Zaha Hadid Design has partnered with porcelain manufacturer Rosenthal to create a new collection of vases. Called the Lapp collection, ...
Aotta launches sound panels made from hemp husks
The panels are designed to maintain 'healthy spaces' and consist of Hemp husks fashioned into a natural porous membrane that absorbs sound
Lauren Heath-Jones
Russian design studio Aotta has developed a range of eco-friendly, sound-absorbing panels made from the waste products of hemp seeds. ...
Mater partners with Ditzel family to create eco-friendly furniture using reclaimed plastic
The furniture uses plastic from recycled fishing nets
Lauren Heath-Jones
Mater, an ethical design brand based in Denmark, has launched a furniture collection made from plastic reclaimed from the ocean. ...
cladkit product news
Zaha Hadid Design partners with Royal Thai to create carpet collection celebrating Zaha Hadid's legacy
The carpets capture Hadid's notable use of layering and interweaving as well as her use of light and shadow
Lauren Heath-Jones
Zaha Hadid Design has partnered with carpet manufacturer Royal Thai to create a new carpet collection inspired by the work ...
David Rockwell partners with Jim Thompson for dream-inspired fabric collection
Rockwell has designed 12 multi-use fabrics inspired by dreams with long-time collaborator Jim Thompson
Lauren Heath-Jones
Renowned architect David Rockwell has created a collection of fabrics with long-time collaborator Jim Thompson. Called Dreams, the collection was ...
Baux creates plant-based acoustic panels
Baux has worked with scientists from the Royal Institute of Technology to create Baux Acoustic Pulp, a plant-derived acoustic solution
Lauren Heath-Jones
Baux, an acoustic products brand based in Sweden, has developed a line of biodegradable acoustic panels, using a plant-based material ...